Crock pot · Fall

Crock pot pot roast, smothered down.

Pot roast is one of my favorite things to make this time of year. It reminds me that it's fall, that it's nesting season, and it just makes me feel so cozy. Our kitchen was torn up the week I made this one, so it went in the crock pot and I did all the prep in the dining room. Yes, on a paper bag. I'm still an old-school paper bag user when I cook.

Part of Table SZN Crock pot 12 to 15 hours
Pulled pot roast with baby gold potatoes and carrots in a bowl with a gold fork
Sunday afternoon, after 12 to 15 hours in the crock pot.

Ingredients

Two chuck roasts, about 3 pounds. It filled my slow cooker. Season it your way.

  • 2 chuck roasts, about 3 lb total
  • Like Sweet Like Smoky by Tabitha Brown (McCormick's salt-free all-purpose blend: garlic, paprika and a little sweet to balance things out)
  • No-salt Cajun seasoning, lots of garlic powder, a little onion powder and black pepper
  • A little olive oil
  • Carrots and celery, cut up
  • Fresh jalapeño
  • Fresh thyme, rosemary and bay leaves
  • 2 packets French onion soup mix
  • A squeeze of tomato paste
  • Onions, sliced, and fresh garlic
  • Water, a splash of chicken broth and a little bouillon
  • Worcestershire sauce
  • Baby gold potatoes
  • Butter and flour for the gravy

Method

  1. Season. Like Sweet Like Smoky by Tabitha Brown, no-salt Cajun, lots of garlic powder and a little onion powder. There's plenty of onion coming, so don't overdo the onion powder.
  2. Brown. Brown the roasts dark on each side. Cut up your carrots and celery while that's happening.
  3. The bottom. Carrots, celery, fresh jalapeño, thyme, rosemary and bay leaves go in the crock pot. It's my variation of the Holy Trinity, with jalapeño because I like a little kick. Pour a packet of French onion soup over the veggies and squeeze some tomato paste on top before the roasts go in. You can stir the paste into the onion mixture instead.
  4. The onions. Sauté the onions in the same pan you browned the meat in, with a little olive oil, so you grab up all that extra flavor. Add more Like Sweet Like Smoky, fresh garlic, jalapeño, a little more pepper and a little no-salt Cajun. Splash some Worcestershire in the pan too.
  5. The broth. In a bowl: water, the second packet of French onion soup, Worcestershire, a splash of chicken broth and a little bouillon. Pour the onions into it when they're done. It saves on space and dishes.
  6. Stack it. Roasts on top of the veggies, pour on the broth, and hold the onions back to pile on last.
  7. Low and slow. It's ready at 10 to 12 hours. I wanted it really smothered down, so mine went 12 to 15, overnight and right up to the Seahawks game the next day. My slow cooker was pretty full, so I skimmed some of the juices off, then put the potatoes on top.
  8. Gravy. Throw a little flour and butter in the pot when you add the potatoes. That's how I usually do it.
Watch the saltI really watched myself on this one, because the two French onion packets and the bouillon bring plenty. That's why the Cajun seasoning is no-salt.
What I'd do differentlyI tried something new this time and thickened the gravy with butter and cornstarch at the end. Next time I'll go back to flour and butter in the pot with the potatoes.
Save your scrapsThis is the season I save my extras: onion paper, garlic paper, the jalapeño ends, leftover rosemary. They go right into the freezer, and in a few weeks they become my chicken broth for Thanksgiving.
Broth poured over a dark-seared chuck roast in a slow cooker
The broth goes on. It looks done, but there are still hours to go.

Print recipe

Come cook with me

A new SZND recipe every Saturday this fall.

Follow along for soups, sides, and everything coming out of my kitchen this season.