Make ahead · Thanksgiving

Mac and cheese, made ahead.

Wednesday is the big day, and the mac and cheese is where it starts. I mix it by hand in the big bowl, cover it, and it goes in the fridge. It bakes Thursday after the turkey comes out. Butter, evaporated milk and eggs, and when I stir it and hear the WAP sound, it's ready. This is one of my three mac and cheese recipes, and it's the base the other two come from.

Part of Table SZN Make ahead One 9x13 pan
Two pans of baked mac and cheese with a deep golden crust in red patterned dishes
May 2026, two pans in a family kitchen in Arizona. The crust is the point.

Ingredients

One 9x13 pan. Double it for two pans; that's my Thanksgiving amount.

  • 1 pound elbow macaroni or cavatappi
  • 1 stick (1/2 cup) butter, plus a little for the dish
  • 1 can (12 ounces) evaporated milk
  • 2 eggs, beaten (3 if you like it firmer)
  • 1 pound cheese, shredded, about 4 cups: sharp cheddar plus other melting cheeses
  • 1 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1 to 2 teaspoons Cajun seasoning
  • 1 teaspoon garlic powder

Method

  1. Noodles. Boil the macaroni in salted water just until tender. Don't overcook it; it bakes again. Drain well.
  2. Butter and season the hot noodles. Into the big bowl. The stick of butter goes straight onto the hot noodles, and you stir until it melts and coats them. The pepper, Cajun seasoning and garlic powder go right on the noodles too, so it's in every bite.
  3. Evaporated milk, a little at a time. Stir it in and let the noodles cool. Hot noodles scramble eggs.
  4. Eggs, then cheese. Beat the eggs and stir them in, then 3 cups of the cheese. Stir until you hear it.
  5. Into the dish. Buttered 9x13, the last cup of cheese heavy on top. Cover and refrigerate. On Thanksgiving week, this is where Wednesday stops.
  6. Bake, then broil. 350°F for 30 to 35 minutes, until the center is set and no longer loose. Then broil 2 to 4 minutes for the cheese crust. Watch it close; it goes from browned to burned fast. Let it rest a few minutes so it sets.
Listen for itStir it and listen for the WAP sound. That's how I know it's right: creamy and holding together, not watery and not dry. Add a splash more milk or another handful of cheese until you hear it.
Why it worksThe butter goes on the hot noodles, not into a sauce, and the seasoning goes on the noodles so it's in every bite. There's no separate cheese sauce. The cheese is stirred right in.
Change the seasoningSame base, different mood: pepper, garlic powder and a little paprika for classic; onion powder and a little smoked seasoning for extra savory; a few dried herbs for herb-forward.
Mom's tableMom gets the traditional one on Thanksgiving. The razzle dazzle is for the rest of the year. Leftovers become Cajun mac and cheese balls, and that recipe is coming after Thanksgiving.
Baked macaroni and cheese with a browned top in a round white dish
May 2024. Same base, a round dish and a different seasoning.

Print recipe

Come cook with me

A new SZND recipe every Saturday this fall.

Follow along for soups, sides, and everything coming out of my kitchen this season.